Home Opinion Alaska (once again) votes to keep ranked choice voting
Opinion

Alaska (once again) votes to keep ranked choice voting

Share
Alaska (once again) votes to keep ranked choice voting
Share

With more than 95 percent of votes tallied, it seems that former Democratic Rep. Mary Peltola will win Alaska’s U.S. Senate seat, defeating the incumbent, Republican Sen. Dan Sullivan.

But by an even more convincing margin, the state’s voters chose to keep its ranked choice voting system.

According to the Alaska Division of Elections, with 100 percent of precincts reporting as of November 14, those who favor keeping it trounced their opponents by more than 7 percentage points.

This is the third time in six years that Alaskans have been asked to consider ranked choice voting. Each time, they have voted in the affirmative, though this is notably the most decisive result.

The results suggest that Alaska likes ranked choice voting, and any candidates who compete in the 49th state should work within it and not keep trying to repeal it.

In November 2020, Alaska narrowly adopted Ballot Measure 2, which instituted two major changes to future elections. First, it replaced partisan primaries, with all candidates for office instead running in a single primary and the top four advancing to the general election. There, in the second major change, voters would rank the four candidates in order of preference; if nobody won an outright majority, then the lowest performer would be eliminated, and each of their votes would be recounted and assigned to their second choices. This would continue until one candidate passed 50 percent.

There was controversy right away: The right-of-center Alaskan Independence Party sued, saying the end of traditional primaries deprived the parties of selecting their own candidates.

The Alaska Supreme Court upheld the law. “The nonpartisan open primary does not burden a party’s ability to choose its standard bearer,” wrote Justice Dario Borghesan, and besides, “political parties do not have a right to a State-run nominating process.”

The new law’s first test came in 2022: Republican Rep. Don Young died in March of that year, vacating the state’s sole U.S. House seat for the first time since 1973. As a result, dozens of candidates ran for the open seat, including Peltola and Republican former Gov. Sarah Palin.

But instead of embracing the new rules, Republicans complained. “It’s bizarre, it’s convoluted, it’s confusing, and it results in voter suppression,” Palin told the crowd at CPAC Texas that year. “It results in a lack of voter enthusiasm because it’s so weird.”

Palin wasn’t alone in her disdain. “Ranked-choice voting is a scheme to rig our elections,” Sen. Tom Cotton (R–Ark.) wrote in 2020, suggesting its primary goal was to trick Republican voters into electing Democrats.

After Peltola won the special election, Palin complained it was a result of voter confusion, that ranked choice voting was an “experiment” that was “crazy, convoluted,” and “confusing,” and she hoped Alaskans would “learn from this voting system mistake and correct it in the next election.”

In fact, after losing a second election to Peltola, Palin was the first to sign a petition to put a repeal of ranked choice voting on the ballot.

“We stand for the Alaskans who felt misled, for those who found the [ranked choice] ballot confusing, and for everyone who believes in the sanctity of the straightforward voting process,” said Phil Izon, head of Alaskans for Honest Elections, the group behind the repeal effort.

In 2024, Alaskans defeated the repeal, but by the slimmest of margins—50.1 percent to 49.9 percent, even narrower than the vote to adopt it in the first place.

Apparently emboldened by the new system’s seeming loss of support, opponents tried yet again, this time with considerably more high-profile backers.

President Donald Trump called ranked choice voting “corrupt” and said it “shouldn’t be allowed in our Country and will, hopefully, be repealed in the November Vote!”

“It is time to bring back a system that puts the voter first. One person, one vote. The candidate with the most votes wins. That’s how our democracy was designed to work,” wrote Alaska Gov. Mike Dunleavy. “I believe when given the chance, we will return to a system that is fair, understandable, and grounded in trust.”

The Alaska Republican Party adopted a resolution in favor of the initiative.

Elon Musk, as part of the $446 million or so that he spent during this election cycle, kicked in $1.5 million to a group supporting the repeal campaign.

Yet despite increased support for repeal, the measure failed by a wide margin, which suggests that ranked choice is here to stay in Alaska.

If anything, Republicans should learn to embrace it: After all, despite Cotton’s claim that its purpose is to disenfranchise Republicans, Lisa Murkowski won reelection to the U.S. Senate in the same year that Palin lost her race for House. And in 2024, Peltola lost her seat to Republican candidate Nick Begich III, the third-place finisher in 2022. While the race will go to ranked choice, Begich looks likely to win reelection this year as well.

“Alaska’s election system has won three times in a row. The message from voters is clear: it’s here to stay,” Meredith Sumpter, president and CEO of FairVote, which supports ranked choice voting, said in an emailed statement. “That’s because ranked choice voting and open primaries are delivering for Alaska. Voters get more choice, elections are more competitive, and candidates need majority support to win elections.”

Source link

Share

Leave a comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Keep in touch

Subscribe to our newsletter to get our newest articles instantly!

    Copyright 2025. All rights reserved