Home Opinion Here’s how we can give Neets a fighting chance | Youth unemployment
Opinion

Here’s how we can give Neets a fighting chance | Youth unemployment

Share
Here’s how we can give Neets a fighting chance | Youth unemployment
Share

Why is Labour reinventing the wheel (Alan Milburn urges Burnham to spend billions on ‘new deal’ for young people, 16 November)? There is an easier and less discriminatory way – and that is through the mainstream education system. This would not dump these young people into a post-16 Neet silo.

Further education (FE) colleges have been working in the area of young people’s training and further education for decades. Yet the sector has been continually undermined by successive governments allowing terrible salary discrimination against the FE sector and by the need to chase numbers (and cash) for A-level-type students. And why has the FE sector has not spoken up effectively for itself?

At the start of my career in an FE college, I taught apprentices – 16-year-olds plus full-time and day-release students – in plumbing, childcare, pre-nursing, catering etc, and advanced apprentices on residential bloc courses. These combined basic education and general studies – learning through training and specific skills training – all working with local and national companies and skilled careers advisers. This all took place in one local college, alongside full- and part-time GCSE and A-level courses for all ages. No discrimination.

Call FE colleges community colleges, and this will start to make sense. Call it Labour investing in the educational sector, not reducing welfare through the back door. The dispossessed young deserve a fresh start at 16 if they want – nurturing, educating and training with respect and parity in the community, and with proper funding, full- or part-time. This is what properly funded FE colleges could be best positioned to provide.

Prof Anne Deighton

Wolfson College, University of Oxford

Amid all the pitch-rolling and fanfare accompanying Alan Milburn’s report, what stands out in sharp relief is his ignorance of the challenges that disabled people like me experience in the workplace. With about 50% of disabled people and 73% of visually impaired people unemployed, there is little evidence that employers are onboard with his proposals.

For Milburn’s plan to stand a chance of succeeding, the government needs to take two steps. First, to take disability discrimination as seriously as other forms of discrimination. Currently, the Equality Act is so porous that employers can discriminate against disabled people with impunity.

Second, they urgently need to overhaul the Access to Work scheme to ensure that disabled people who are fortunate enough to be offered a job receive the additional support they need in a timely manner. I know disabled people who have had offers of employment withdrawn because Access to Work has taken too long.

Without making these changes, Milburn’s proposals will not get the support they need from the people who matter most – young disabled people.

Tom Walker

Liverpool

It is interesting that in all the discussions I’ve heard about ways to help young people into work, only the private sector has been mentioned in relation to apprenticeships and work experience. No mention has been made of the vast state employers such as the NHS.

As the biggest UK employer, does this government not see itself as having a significant direct role to play? Similarly, local government hasn’t entered the frame. Without the active involvement of these institutions, Milburn’s objectives of making a significant dent in the existence of nearly 1 million young people not in education, employment or training will never be met. There are just not enough hotels, restaurants or shops.

Adrin Neatrour

Newcastle upon Tyne

Amid debate over the billions needed to tackle youth joblessness let us not overlook a step that costs nothing. Employers replying kindly to every young applicant, including unsolicited ones, would stop young people feeling unworthy of even basic human courtesy. Small things matter.

Alan C Coppin

Former chair, Include charity

Have an opinion on anything you’ve read in the Guardian today? Please email us your letter and it will be considered for publication in our letters section.

Source link

Share

Leave a comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Keep in touch

Subscribe to our newsletter to get our newest articles instantly!

    Copyright 2025. All rights reserved