Home Lifestyle ‘The platonic ideal of a wine glass’: we test the best for every budget | Wine
Lifestyle

‘The platonic ideal of a wine glass’: we test the best for every budget | Wine

Share
‘The platonic ideal of a wine glass’: we test the best for every budget | Wine
Share

It is a truth only sometimes acknowledged that wine is in want of a good drinking vessel. Why? Because wine experts agree that the shape, character and feel of a glass give wine the conditions to shine.

“A good glass can greatly improve your experience,” writes David Williams in The Encyclopedia of Wine. He adds that expense isn’t necessary: “[A]s a rule, the thinner the glass the better, while an oval shape and generous (but not enormous) bowl are best at capturing and releasing a wine’s flavours.” Drinking wine is an experience beyond flavour; before the taste, there is the nose, and a good glass will amplify its aromas. Likewise, there is the ineffable question of how a wine makes us feel; again, your choice of glass feeds into this experience – how does it feel to hold, to swirl, to sip from?

I think wine drinkers can be split into two camps: those that buy into this idea (like me) and those who don’t (like my father). He thinks I’m pretentious; I think he’s misguided. Of the former camp, there are two further subgroups. First, there’s the niche crew who believe in varietal-specific glasses, behind which there’s always a compellingly geeky rationale. For example, riesling glasses are small with a relatively wide bowl that narrows towards the top to direct the wine’s delicate aromas to your nose, while tall goblet-like Bordeaux glasses have a generous bowl for swirling, which allows these big, structured wines to release their aromas and be at their most expressive (a sentence that begs a nerd face emoji, sorry).

I’ll confess to loving the nerdery, but I don’t have the budget or cabinet space for all that. And so I find myself in the second subgroup, an enthusiast of the universal wine glass, an all-purpose receptacle designed for wine of any colour and such a multitasker you don’t even need champagne flutes. I know!

It’s this group of all-rounder glasses that I’ve tested here. Importantly, most of the glasses that identify as universal are premium options – the Zaltos and Richard Brendons of this world – and I tested those, but I also tested a range of other self-described “wine glasses” that were not marketed for a specific grape variety. Unless you’re of the riesling anorak ilk, there is something for everyone here – for all budgets and styles of wine.


Why you should trust me

“I like drinking” isn’t a phrase I’ve used to qualify myself before, but it matters here; choosing a glass is about having the best possible experience of a wine. You’ve got to want to enjoy it. I’ve had brushes with all manner of drinking vessels over the years, from American red Solo cups to paper-thin hand-blown glassware, and I’m no stranger to the difference a good glass makes.

Aside from being your wine columnist here at the Guardian, I’m a tired mum of two in her 40s, and the reasons I drink wine have changed. These days, I take time over a glass or two and want that experience to be as lovely as possible, so I’m invested in good glassware.

How I tested

As I was assessing these as universal wine glasses, I tested with a range of different wines – a 12C sparkling, a chilled white and a room-temperature red – over a number of weeks. I poured a taste into each of the glasses in the running, filling it no more than a third full. I gave each a swirl before tasting. I judged each glass on a number of criteria: its aesthetic; its practicality (whether it’s dishwasher safe, or how easy it is to wash up and dry); its ability to concentrate the wine’s aromas; how clearly I could see the wine; whether it allowed the wine to breathe; how comfortable it was to hold and to drink from; and the ineffable metric of how much joy it brought me.

I should caveat that, while I love a practical piece of kit, when it comes to wine glasses, I’m personally happy to wash them up. It’s important to note that what I deem to be a great wine glass in terms of doing a wine justice – not to mention enhancing your enjoyment of it – may not be the most practical when it comes to washing and avoiding breakages. In other words, I wasn’t judging on practicality alone.


The best wine glasses


Best wine glass overall:

Richard Brendon x Jancis Robinson

Photograph: Mina Holland/The Guardian
£96 for two at Selfridges (£48 each)
£96 for two at Borough Kitchen (£48 each)

★★★★★

The platonic ideal of a wine glass: perfectly proportioned with an elegant tulip shape – a bowl that’s rotund enough for swirling (9cm at its widest) and curves up to a narrower rim that is wide enough for comfort, but narrow enough to concentrate those aromas. It is mouth-blown and has a gossamer-thin rim and stem – but not so much that I’m scared to handle it. It has a relatively wide base too, the same diameter as the widest part of the bowl, which makes it feel stable in spite of its delicacy.

The fact that this was designed in collaboration with the wine writer and master of wine Jancis Robinson feels like the ultimate seal of approval. Incidentally, Robinson champions the idea that none of us need more than one shape of wine glass, which I suppose is why she embarked upon designing her own universal number with Richard Brendon. She believes that “just one glass for all wines makes perfect practical sense”, insisting that white wines deserve just as much space to breathe and move as reds – likewise sparkling and fortified wines. I am with her: give me a cabinet full of these over a scarcely used mix of varietal-specific glasses any day. At this price, I personally wouldn’t dare put them in the dishwasher, although the brand recommends that you clean them this way, putting them on the top shelf and using glass-friendly detergent.


Best budget wine glass:

Tesco F&F Home premium wine glasses

Photograph: Mina Holland/The Guardian
£14 for four at Tesco (£3.50 each)

★★★★☆

I’m so impressed by this glass! For only £3.50 a pop, you get a generous bowl and proportions that mimic all the best stemmed universal glasses in this test. What you lose in graceful, papery thinness, you gain in practicality: this was happy in the dishwasher. Also, if you’re new to swirling wine (there is a knack to it!), I think the relative heaviness of the bowl and stem helps steady the hand.


Best everyday wine glass:

Lehmann F Sommier Psyché universal wine glasses

Photograph: Mina Holland/The Guardian
£110 for six at Borough Kitchen (£18.33 each)

★★★★★

These are superb and, next to the likes of Zalto and Richard Brendon, good value at £18.33 a glass. They have the most generous bowl of all the finer glasses I tested; although technically universal, I’d say they’re particularly well suited to vintage wines and complex reds. That said, since the test, this has been the glass I have kept reaching for day-to-day, especially if I have wines to taste for my column – it is one of Lehmann’s most premium machine-made glasses, so feels a bit more everyday than some of the more expensive options. Also dishwasher safe, although I think all these glassmakers would prefer us to be hand-washing.


Best wine glass for special occasions:

Zalto universal wine glasses

Photograph: Mina Holland/The Guardian
£100 for two at Borough Kitchen (£50 each)
£50 each at Selfridges

★★★★☆

These are cult wine glasses – so revered that I know a sommelier who named their dog after them. They’re also improbably thin – the rim is half a millimetre thick. I was given a set as a wedding present and there might only be one left. For this reason, they’re used rarely – for special wines, or if it’s only me and my partner drinking. Guests don’t want the responsibility! Zalto says they are dishwasher safe but … over my dead body.


Best wine glass for parties:

Olympia short-stemmed wine glasses

Photograph: Mina Holland/The Guardian
£17.62 for six at Nisbets (£2.94 each)

★★★★☆

This short, stubby-stemmed glass is a popular style in bistros, and similar ones are used at the food and wine institution St John. I confess to having loads in my possession: I serve everything from fizz to chilled reds in them. At this price, I don’t need to be precious about breakages – rare in any case since they are so robust. Only 13.5cm high with a maximum diameter of 7.8cm, they are stubby and fun. They lack the height or bowl for breathing and swirling, so I wouldn’t particularly choose these for serious, complex wines, but they’re great for everything from vin de table to party plonk.

skip past newsletter promotion



The rest of the test (from best to worst)


Iittala Lempi glasses

Photograph: Mina Holland/The Guardian
£27.50 for two at Nordic Nest (£13.75 each)
£29.77 for two at Formadore (£14.89 each)

★★★★☆

Gorgeous, multi-talented drinking glasses. They serve a similar function to the Olympia glasses above – short-stemmed, and great for casual, group drinking – but come at a higher price. I prefer the design, but I think they’re a bit too dear for a party glass. For a little more per glass, you’re better off going for the Lehmann Psyché, with its superior height, fineness and elegance. They’re dishwasher safe.


Bloomingville Signe drinking glasses

Photograph: Mina Holland/The Guardian
£48 for six at Flannels (£8 each)

★★★☆☆

I was seduced by the colour scheme of these, which gives Nigella in her pink-and-green era, circa 2015. But bells and whistles like tinted glass don’t serve wine well. The green bowl makes it impossible to decipher the subtlety of the wine’s hue – is it a deep purple beaujolais or an auburn nebbiolo? Who knows! I love them for water and table wine, however; they’ll look very at home on a festive table. They’re not suitable for the dishwasher.


Toast recycled Bolivian wine glasses

Photograph: Mina Holland/The Guardian
£36 for four at Toast (£9 each)

★★★☆☆

I’m fond of this style as it’s what my granny used. I remember her dipping a crust of bread into wine in one of these glasses: communio-at-home vibes. But this is a thick glass and, because it is relatively small, you won’t get a good swirl from it. Oh, and in my experience, small glasses are dangerous – they need refilling a lot! They’re dishwasher safe.


Nkuku Sigiri small wine glasses

Photograph: Mina Holland/The Guardian
£33.60 for four at Nkuku (£8.40 each)

★★★☆☆

Mouth-blown with thick, recycled glass, these rustic vessels have a kind of dangly earringed bohemian charm. But they’re too small, too chunky and too decorative to do serious wines justice. I rather like the idea of them on the Christmas table, though; I can imagine the rough fluting of the glass catching candlelight. And I did like them for a simple red wine. They’re dishwasher safe, too.


Habitat bobbin glasses

Photograph: Mina Holland/The Guardian
£13.50 for four at Argos with code COSY25 (£3.38 each)

★★☆☆☆

I’m a fan of Habitat’s bobbin range – a modern reinterpretation of 17th-century bobbin furniture – and have several of its lamps and picture frames. I didn’t need to add the wine glasses. I appreciate the thought that’s gone into the design, but the fluting obscures the wine inside – it’s harder to see, for example, the “legs” the wine leaves on the sides (an indication of alcohol by volume), and the overall effect is chunky. They’re dishwasher safe.


Ichendorf Milano Courgette optical stemmed wine glass

Photograph: Mina Holland/The Guardian
£24.99 each at Sous Chef

★★☆☆☆

Someone described this as the Liberace of wine glasses, which is about right. It is one of an irresistible range of produce (chilli, carrot, cauliflower; I chose courgette). If you’re into wine, I wouldn’t necessarily recommend spending £24.99 on a phallic vegetable-themed vessel – really it’s a glass cup on an eccentric stem, so works much like the other small-bowled glasses here, better for table wine. It would make a great present for any wine-drinking courgette growers in your life, though. They’re dishwasher safe at low temperatures.


Beldi Country Club Moroccan wine glasses

Photograph: Mina Holland/The Guardian
£32 for six at Lamp (£5.34 each)

★☆☆☆☆

Another very stylised option. This was my least favourite because the base is part of the vessel for the wine itself, so if you’re holding your drink for any length of time, your hands will impart temperature to it – which obviously isn’t desirable for any wine you want to drink below body temperature (which is all wine! But especially fizz, whites and rosés – so you couldn’t call this a universal glass). Add to that the (very beautiful) olive colour, which obscures the colour of its contents, and this doesn’t seem like a glass I could conceivably impose on a decent wine. They’re dishwasher safe.

For more, read our guide to the best mid-strength drinks and what to bring to a dinner party


Mina Holland is a London-based food and drink writer and editor



Source link

Share

Leave a comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Keep in touch

Subscribe to our newsletter to get our newest articles instantly!

    Copyright 2025. All rights reserved